Final Fantasy XIV’s Housing F&#kapooloza 2017


I played Final Fantasy XIV since 2010’s alpha. I recruited a large group of friends into playing around 1.23, Realm Reborn, and Heavensward’s launches. I’ve enjoyed its many successes, minus one thing: housing.

When the playerbase exploded around Realm Reborn’s hype and launch, I was surprised to see Balmung turn from a relatively tiny community into the very same server some players on Mateus are complaining about being too large right now. 

The housing areas were bought out so quickly I never had a chance to get a small plot. When apartments were released, I managed to get one – on the sub-ward – after staying up until 2 am on a work night, waiting in a long queue, then panicking after being glitched behind the new building. A few of my friends snagged an apartment as well. Most of my friends didn’t.

Some of my friends had to buy the game/its expansion, set up their subscription, make their character on another server, then pay about $15 for a transfer to Balmung to get around its closed-but-not-entirely-closed-gates-of-entry. We wanted to play together. We found a way to. Then were were stuck because changing servers would cost a crap ton of money.

Then Square Enix released their New World and World Population Balancing Incentives. This meant a new start on a new server – Mateus – and the possibility to finally own a damned house. When I transferred I had about 1.5m, so I started working toward hitting the 2m mark, and so on. Balancing that and work has been really hard lately, but things were looking up.

Then news spread that wards were quickly filling. My new Mateus friend, who owns a lot of land, said he’ll loan me the rest of the money if I could find an small open plot.

I checked Lavendar Beds. Nothing. Traveled to Mist. Nada. Close to tears from frustration, I teleported to The Goblet. Nich.

As my blood pressure rose, I noticed something different about Goblet, Ward 12. The entire ward was owned by two people. I logged out and haven’t logged in since. Queue rant:

Going against the flow of the average MMO community


Some players have been defending Martyr and Seraph’s “ownership” of these homes when they bought them. At the time Mateus was low pop, so its players had ample opportunity to participate in housing-only content. Most houses on that server were never utilized until the recent world balancing initiatives.

Meanwhile, most players in servers like Balmung and Gilgamesh have had a comparatively difficult time dealt with an impenetrable and brutally frustrating lack of housing space for years.

This is indicative of Square Enix’s distribution of server resources actively disparaging the way that FFXIV’s community has settled itself as a staple and longstanding MMORPG. Instead of supporting its players settling en masse on a few major servers (Worlds 1 and 2 on RuneScape, Proudmoore and Dalaran on WoW, Freeport on EQ2, I could go on and on), SE has proven incapable of properly supporting its larger servers with more housing instances. Or queue times. Or pretty much anything. Yoshi-P and their team have had years to fix this. A band-aid does not fix a flood.

The Balmung RP community has been in turmoil. During 1.0’s failed launch, the unofficial roleplay server, chosen via player vote, was Besaid. That server was fused with Fabul (I think it was Fabul) to make Balmung, the very server SE is now shutting down new characters/transfers for. Roleplay communities rely on new blood to continue thriving, and this group managed to stay organized and active for longer and at a much larger scale than usually seen in MMOs. Now they’ve settled on Mateus. How ironic.

I’m far more interested in supporting FFXIV’s RP community than I am in Martyr and Seraph’s “ownership” of server resources that should have been allocated to Balmung and Gilgamesh in the first place. I’m concerned about new players and Free Companies missing out on some of the key social tools that make FFXIV more than just an occasionally-multiplayer Final Fantasy game.

Seraph Altima and Kotaku

(From Kotaku)

Martyr and Seraph don’t own anything. Square Enix has rights to all its property, including the very characters whose names I’m mentioning. They’re paying a subscription fee every month like everyone else.

This last Thursday, Kotaku released an article about this whole mess. In it, Seraph said something that got me thinking.

Of course, some players still think they should be able to get those houses. “Not everyone needs everything in-game,” counters Altima. She argues that she’s not depriving anyone of housing; the plots were empty for years before they took them. “For example, not everyone deserves the Savage raiding mounts if they don’t do Alexander.”

Last time I checked, the Alexander raids aren’t Moonfire Faire, Little Ladies Day, or any other limited-time event FFXIV has every year. Every player, newbie or veteran, will have access to Alexander savage raid mounts as long as online services are provided. Alexander raids, unlike housing, does not have a hard cap on how many players can participate before the gates are closed indefinitely.

This isn’t about whether or not players need or deserve player housing. The issue is about access. And she is depriving players of access to housing, regardless of what she says. The system she’s taking advantage of is completely broken.

Her Tumblr post swathed in ego and self-justification doesn’t win her any sympathy from me. Here’s a gem before I move on:

And then SE closed Balmung and Gilgamesh, and Mateus was invaded. And suddenly, people care about Mateus housing for the first time in nearly three years. Suddenly, people think we are *the* worst people. Because how dare we enjoy the game in the manner we chose to enjoy it.

How dare we?

How dare you.

You, who finally deign to set foot in my home. You, who hated Mateus for all the same reasons I felt it was perfect. You, who would take away the last year of memories I’ve made with one of the best friends I’ve ever known. You, who don’t care about the fact that we have cultivated something unique, interesting, and amazing, because you feel it denies you the chance to throw up a hideous paissa wall and plop a chocobo stable and a garden plot in front of an otherwise unused black hole with Dragonsong screeching away in the background. You, with your head so buried in your cliques that you thought we came from Balmung within the last month and achieved all this thanks to SE’s allowance of free infinite gil transfers, not realizing we wanted to be here, that we love it here, that we worked our asses off for all this from nothing but the million gil each we were allowed to bring with us from our mains.

How dare you.

The people harassing her and her friend need to stop. That said, after reading the entirety of her Tumblr post I don’t feel as bad about it happening in the first place. Just being honest.

An Issue with Access


Access is important when it comes to providing a paid service. The FFXIV player pays a monthly fee to gain access to, and support the ongoing development and maintenance of, FFXIV’s player housing system. It doesn’t matter if that player has a house or not.

Player housing is one of the most requested features in any MMO. Housing is as much a selling point for MMOs as survival systems are for open world games.

In my opinion, every player who pays a monthly fee should have the ability to save up gold – either alone or together in a guild – and buy a house. With no issues, using systems developed and supported into the game.

FFXIV’s player housing “market” has developed as a result of the game’s issue with access. Players take advantage of the lack of available plots and sell them/trade them to other players by quickly “opening up” access to the plot publicly, or by transferring ownership of free companies. This will not do either, especially compared to other MMOs that have more accessible housing systems (most of these games don’t even require subscriptions).

Players have been advocating restricting houses to one character and guild per data center, but the housing plots would still be finite and too few.

Square Enix has implemented a system that limits how many houses are available, and continues to allow players to buy multiple lots. The blame rests completely on Square Enix.

Taking a Long Break


Yoshi-P announced that the new housing zone, Shirogane, will be released with the 4.1 patch. Adding another set amount of finite instances won’t stop richer players from owning and selling multiple houses, thus perpetuating a system that actively prevents other players from participating in a large chunk of content that they pay to support.

Also, I’m not staying up until past 2 AM on a work night for the chance that I’ll get a house. I expect housing in Shirogane will fill faster than normal (on Mateus) for these reasons:

  • It’s the first patch after the expansion launch; the playerbase will continue to peak until it inevitably declines in size around the launch of 4.2 or 4.3.
  • Players are receiving millions of Gil by giving up their apartments during transfer, or leveling an alt character to 30. (I heard buying boosts also gives Gil.)
  • 4.1’s far-off launch will give players ample time to save up Gil, so there will be considerably more competition.
  • Shirogane is really, really Japanese. It’s kawaii no desu ne uguu sugoi. It’s so anime it hurts. Physically. Where my heart used to be.
  • Lots of talking about housing gets players thinking about getting a house.

I don’t feel comfortable continuing to pay a monthly fee to support this. It goes against my values as a gamer and consumer. I’m especially not okay with the idea of paying to support assholes like Seraph Altima. Since this shitstorm started, I’ve had difficulty finding the urge to log in. This is sad because Stormblood is a really great expansion when it comes to pretty much everything else.

As much as I want to finish the story, I’m unsubbing. I can’t take it anymore. I’ve waited years for a house in this game, while at the same time reading in FC/LS chat about people owning upwards of 4-5 houses at the same time. My friends have waited years to get a FC house – after scrounging up 7m, all the houses are gone on Mateus.

I won’t resub until every player or guild who wants a house has complete access to gaining one, given the effort. Those of you reading this don’t have to agree with me, but I hope sharing my perspective will at least get some people thinking.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s